Beyond the Swipe

Finding Real Connection in a Gamified Dating World

I was talking to a friend last week who told me she'd been on seven first dates in the past month. Seven. When I asked how they went, she just shrugged and said, "They were fine, I guess. But I already have three more lined up for next week."

This is where we are now. Dating has become this weird hybrid of shopping and gaming, where there's always another option just a swipe away. And honestly? It's exhausting everyone.

I remember when meeting someone new felt like a big deal. You'd get nervous, overthink what to wear, maybe even call a friend for advice. Now we're scheduling first dates like dentist appointments and treating people like they're returnable if they don't spark joy in the first fifteen minutes.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not nostalgic for the days when you had to hope you'd randomly bump into your soulmate at the grocery store. Dating apps have genuinely helped people connect who never would have crossed paths otherwise. But somewhere along the way, we've confused having options with having connections.

🧠 The Psychology of Infinite Choice

Here's what I've noticed about myself and pretty much everyone I know who uses dating apps: we've all gotten a little addicted to the possibility of something better. You're on a perfectly nice date with someone who checks most of your boxes, but in the back of your mind, you're wondering about the three other matches sitting in your phone.

It's not that we're all commitment-phobic or shallow. It's that these apps are designed to keep us engaged, scrolling, always looking for the next match. Every notification gives you a little hit of dopamine. Every new match makes you feel like you're making progress, even when you're just collecting conversations that go nowhere.

The apps train your brain to value novelty over depth. Why invest in getting to know someone when there are 50 other people you haven't even messaged yet? Why work through that awkward first-date energy when you could just swipe right on someone new?

But here's the thing: real connection doesn't work like that. It's not about finding the perfect person who gives you butterflies from minute one. It's about finding someone you can build something with, even when it starts slow or feels uncertain.

🤝 What Creates Real Connection

Get clear on what you want. This sounds obvious, but many people open dating apps without really knowing why. Are you bored? Lonely? Looking for validation? Ready for a relationship? There's no wrong answer, but being honest about your motivation changes how you show up.

If you're using dating apps as entertainment when you're stressed or can't sleep, you're probably not going to make meaningful connections. When you're not available for connection, when you're just looking for distraction, it shows in how you engage with people.

Move conversations offline quickly. The longer you stay in the app, the more you're both performing instead of connecting. If someone isn't interested in moving to texting or a phone call within a few days, they're probably not serious about meeting anyone. And that's fine, it just saves everyone time.

Be real from the start. Many people think they need to be this perfectly curated version of themselves on dating apps. Witty bio, carefully selected photos, clever opening lines. But here's the thing: the people who are attracted to that polished version might not like the real you. And the people who might be a good fit could be swiping past because you seem too rehearsed or are trying too hard.

Try a more straightforward approach. Use recent photos that look like you on a normal day. Write messages like you're talking to a friend, not auditioning for a comedy show. Ask genuine questions because you're curious about the answers.

Trust your gut about chemistry. It's tempting to think that if someone looks good on paper, shared interests, similar values, and good conversation, then the chemistry will develop over time. Sometimes it does. But sometimes it just doesn't, and that's not anyone's fault.

Pay attention to how you feel during and after interactions. Do you feel energized or drained? Are you looking forward to seeing them again or coming up with excuses to postpone? Your body usually knows before your brain does.

❤️ The Real Challenge

The hardest part about dating in the app era isn't finding people to go out with, it's staying present with the person you're actually with. When you know you have other options, it's easy to check out mentally during dates, to treat every interaction like a job interview instead of a chance to connect with another human being.

It's such a terrible way to approach getting to know someone. Nobody gets to show you who they are when you're constantly comparing them to hypothetical alternatives.

The people I know who've found great relationships through dating apps all did the same thing: they got off the apps as soon as they met someone worth getting to know better. They didn't keep their profiles active "just in case." They didn't keep swiping while they were figuring out if there was potential with someone real.

“Love isn’t built in a scroll. It’s built in presence.”

💭 Final Thoughts

What if we treated dating apps like what they are, a tool for introductions, not a substitute for real connection? What if we used them to meet people, then quickly moved into the messy, imperfect, non-gamified world of actual human relationships?

I'm not saying you should marry the first person who doesn't immediately annoy you. I'm saying maybe we could give people more than three dates to reveal themselves. Maybe we could have conversations about what we're looking for instead of trying to decode it from their choice of emojis. Maybe we could remember that the goal isn't to optimize our dating life, it's to find someone we want to stop dating other people for.

The apps aren't going anywhere, and they don't have to be the enemy. But they also don't have to be the entire relationship. They're just the introduction. What you do with that introduction, how present you are, how honest you are, how willing you are to be a little vulnerable and see what happens, that's still up to you.

And honestly? That's the part that matters anyway.

💡 Want to go deeper?
Subscribe to the MTS Premium Newsletter for in-depth mindset strategies and subscriber-only editions.